Little Italy Pizzeria
Welcome to Little Italy Pizzeria, your go-to destination for authentic, mouthwatering pizza in the heart of Athens, Georgia! Located at 125 N Lumpkin St, our charming pizzeria is perfectly positioned to serve both locals and visitors alike. With a stellar rating of 4.4 stars, we pride ourselves on delivering an exceptional dining experience that keeps our customers coming back for more. Whether you're a fan of thick crust, a lover of gourmet toppings, or simply in search of a cozy spot to enjoy a meal with family and friends, Little Italy Pizzeria is here to satisfy your cravings. At Little Italy, we understand the art of pizza-making. Our menu features a variety of delicious options, from classic pepperoni to unique gourmet specialties, all crafted with fresh ingredients and a passion for flavor. Customers rave about our signature Antipasto, laden with quality meats and cheeses, and our perfectly cooked pizzas that strike just the right balance of crunch and chew. With convenient hours from 11 AM to 3 AM on weekends and late-night dining on weekdays, we’re here to serve you at any hour. Whether you're grabbing a slice after a night out or enjoying a family dinner, our friendly staff, including standout team members like Will and Ian, ensure that you're met with patience and a smile. Join us for a meal and see why so many have declared Little Italy Pizzeria a must-visit in Athens. While we strive for perfection, we also appreciate feedback to continuously improve our offerings. Our commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in our attentive service and delicious food. So, whether you're a first-time visitor or a returning fan, we invite you to experience the warmth and flavor of Little Italy Pizzeria. For more updates, feel free to check us out on our Facebook page or give us a call at +1 706-613-7100!
Photos
Videos (5 total)
Showing 1 of 5 videos
Reviews & Questions
Google Reviews
J. H.
The thick crusted pizza is phenomenal. Will and Ian were running the place with ease. We were helped deciding on what to get and met with patience and a smile. I had two small kids with me so I appreciated that. For the price you can’t beat the quality and quantity of food. The toppings were plentiful and the sauce definitely tastes homemade.
Ruth Montes
The Antipasto was packed with the meat and cheese. The pizza was perfectly cooked. Had an amazing crunchy crust with the perfect ratio of crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. The amount of pepperoni on the pizza was above and beyond. I don’t know what kind of pepperoni they use but it was delicious. Definitely 2 thumbs up from these NY Italian Mamas
James fc
Made my pizza wrong, charged extra. When I got home to eat it it actually tasted inedible, like something was wrong with it. They said they have to talk to everyone to see what happened just to give me a refund. They said if they just gave a refund to everyone who complained about their pizza they would go out of buainess... I had forgot, but the last time I ordered here they just gave my pizza to a thief and refused to remake it, too. Terrible place, they still owe me a refund, but I don't think I can go back after the taste of the last pizza and how they have treated a decades-long customer Also, it is illegal to charge extra for people using debit cards.
Mike C
If you know me I don't do reviews unless I have been to the establishment on three visits unless it is extremely disappointing or exceptional. This place is exceptional. I even did a video for this place that's the impression it made on me and my unexpected taste buds. Phenomenal is the word that comes to mind delicious is right there with the first word you could use them and feel them interchangeably when eating here. The love given to the fresh ingredients are top notch, but the love and care given to prepare said ingredients are uplifting. When I say the big hat dreadlocks man checked on that pie like a hawk and was a complete artisan of this field.... Mind blowing 🤯. I say that to say this if you are ever about 2 hours out from this spot come make the detor to get more!! Crazy great !!
Leslie
Great pizza! First time in Athens and was told that Little Italy was a must that no matter how long the line was to just wait in it. There was definitely a wait but wowwww the pizza didn't disappoint! We got a small half cheese/half pep thick crust! Can't wait to go back! I will say its not a big building so finding a hard to
William C. Albert
Wow!! The pizza is fantastic here! The crust is perfect, crispy but not too crispy. Made my own William special pizza, 4 cheese, extra Mozzarella with red sauce, pepperoni's and meatballs. They knocked it out of the park. Best pizza I have had in a long while! Worth the drive and pretty downtown area to walk it off after.
Mark Kennedy
This little pizza joint kicked ar$e! Best thin crust we've had in years. Beer & sweet tea at a cheap price for a college town. This place had a quiet vibe and awesome staff.
Srinivas Komma
Little Italy Pizza in Athens, Georgia, offers authentic New York-style pizza with a perfectly thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and generous portions make it a local favorite for both students and residents alike.
Nisha Sims
Good food but needs to invest in a pick up counter. If the line is out of the door and you called in a pick up order. There is no need to tell the customer that they need to wait in line. By the time you get your food, it’s cold. Don’t offer pick up services if you have to go through additional measures just to get your food and at that point it’s not even satisfying. Additionally, the staff on the phone when placing the order is definitely unpleasant and sounded like she didn’t want to be there nor take my order.
Nevaeh Marie
Stopped by for a little treat with my wife and needless to say it made our entire trip. The gentleman at the front counter was so extremely respectful and helpful through the ordering process, answering all of our questions and joking around with us. The older gentleman who prepared our pizzas joked around with us as well, very caring and generous with the toppings. Shoutout to Little Italy for making the biggest, most fresh, delicious slices I’ve ever had.
